Telemachus in Sparta
The strangest domestic scene in Homer: Helen, back in her husband's house, drugs the wine so the company can talk about Troy without weeping.
In the poem
Telemachus arrives during a double wedding feast and is struck by the brightness of the hall. Menelaus tells him about the returns; Helen drops a drug from Egypt into the wine and both of them tell stories about Odysseus at Troy, hers flattering and his less so.
The setting is a palace with a courtyard, guest quarters and enough wealth to compare to Olympus. Laconia has produced no such building, which makes this the most vivid Homeric interior with the least material behind it.
Why it matters for the atlas
It is the test case for Sparta: a scene rich enough to be checked against archaeology, in a region whose Bronze Age centre has never been found.
Competing theories
- Plausible
The Menelaion at Therapne
Proposed by: British School at Athens excavations · Modern
The place Greeks themselves associated with Menelaus and Helen, with Mycenaean buildings underneath an archaic cult. Evidence of belief, and of Bronze Age occupation; not evidence of the palace the poem describes.
Sparta (Lacedaemon)- ArchaeologyExcavations at the Menelaion, Therapne — Mycenaean mansions and an archaic sanctuary of Menelaus and Helen
- Primary textHerodotus, Histories 6.61 — the shrine of Helen at Therapne
What is disputed
Whether a palace of this class exists undiscovered in the Eurotas valley, or whether the Odyssey furnished Menelaus with a hall from elsewhere.
Questions
- Has the palace of Menelaus been found?
- No. Laconia has Mycenaean mansions at the Menelaion and an early cult of Menelaus and Helen, but no palace comparable to Pylos or Mycenae has been excavated.
- Is Helen's Egyptian drug a real detail?
- It is consistent with the poem's wider picture of Egypt as a source of exotic goods and knowledge, which is itself consistent with real Aegean contact with Egypt. That is context, not confirmation.
Sources
- Primary textHomer, Odyssey (trans. A. T. Murray, Loeb, 1919)
- ArchaeologyExcavations at the Menelaion, Therapne — Mycenaean mansions and an archaic sanctuary of Menelaus and Helen
- Primary textHerodotus, Histories 6.61 — the shrine of Helen at Therapne